Roofing Materials

Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing in Colorado: An Honest Cost Comparison

Gray roof with two dormer windows
Metal lasts longer and sheds snow, but asphalt costs half as much. Here is how to decide for a Denver-area home.

Two out of three homeowners we meet ask the same question: is metal worth the extra money? The honest answer depends on how long you will stay, your insurance and what the next hailstorm brings.

What each roof costs in the Denver metro

  • Class 4 architectural asphalt: about $5.50 to $7 per square foot installed. A typical home runs $12,000 to $22,000.
  • Standing seam metal: about $11 to $15 per square foot installed. A typical home runs $24,000 to $45,000.

How long they last at altitude

Intense UV at our elevation shortens shingle life. Expect 20 to 25 years from a quality asphalt roof in Denver, versus 50 or more from standing seam metal.

Hail and insurance

Class 4 impact-rated shingles hold up far better than standard shingles, and many insurers offer a discount for them. Metal resists penetration, but large hail can dent it cosmetically, so read your policy for cosmetic damage exclusions.

Snow, ice and fire

Metal sheds snow quickly and carries a Class A fire rating, which matters in the foothills and near open space. Asphalt is also Class A when installed over the right underlayment.

Our rule of thumb: staying 15 years or more, near the foothills, or planning solar? Look hard at metal. Otherwise a Class 4 asphalt roof is the best value.

Every Peakline estimate can include both options side by side, so you can compare real numbers for your home.

Share this article
In this article

Free drone inspection

A 21-point check with photos of every slope and a written report within 24 hours.

Roof leaking right now?

Same-day emergency tarping, 7 days a week. We photograph everything for your insurer.

Keep reading

More from the blog.